
Ivan Kliun, Spherical construction (Red light), collaged
Last week, I published a short piece offering some initial thoughts about why young men swung right between the 2020 and 2024 elections, and what that can tell us about the online social spaces where those young men spend their time. My theory1 was that the right wing developed an alternative media on platforms that were once viewed as less-than-mainstream (by which I’m mostly referring to video platforms like YouTube, and now, by extension, TikTok) concurrently with those platforms cementing their place in culture and style. This has granted the right a kind of home field advantage on platforms that are extraordinarily popular with young people.2
Now, behind the sub-wall, as a treat for the real Grevheads, I wanted to think out loud about some of the conversations that have followed (e.g. “we need to engineer a leftist Joe Rogan”) and link out to a few articles (and tweets) on similar subjects that I’ve found interesting and useful.
I don’t want to get too far away from the core competencies of this newsletter, so I’ll be back to covering more explicitly game-y and esports-y subjects in the next newsletter. In writing this piece, I also don’t want to imply that the subject of “men, aged 18-29” is synonymous with games and the internet. But if you’re a citizen of the internet, you’ve probably felt the pull of some of the trends brought to the fore by the 2024 election, so I’d like to discuss those here. As before, I’m just thinking out loud/working things out on the fly here.
So, to start: Can the left build its own Joe Rogan? The answer is obviously no.

Welcome to the comments.
One rule: Be normal. Thanks!
Reply
or to participate
Brendan Husebo2 years ago
Did you listen to the latest Slow Burn series on the rise of Fox News? Felt prescient to make that his pre-election focus.
Lined up next to the post-election reading, it doesn't even seem like a prologue. It sounds more like the original trilogy before 2024's rehashed sequel with stolen tropes.
The parallels with MSNBC slowly rising up to be the counterweight in a two-sided establishment are interesting. But episodes 4 and 5 were pretty much your list. The 'Fox has fans, CNN has users'. The cynicism and inevitable passivity of The Daily Show. The 'we need our own Bill O'Reiley' and then just relying on Al Franken and not realising there'll always be another O'Reiley. The funding asymmetry in a media war between left and right.
Mikhail KlimentovAuthor2 years ago
Whoa, I have not listened, but it sounds fascinating. Really spot on. I mean, in some respects, here's hoping these things kind of happen in cycles, just so there's some blueprint to fall back on wrt what NOT to do.